Guide

Ethical review incentives: FTC guidelines and best practices (2026)

Teams offer gift cards for reviews, then wonder why the FTC sent a warning letter. Incentives are legal when disclosed and structured correctly — but they cannot buy five-star fiction. This guide covers FTC endorsement basics, ethical incentive types, disclosure copy, moderation, and why guided interviews produce authentic reviews even with a small thank-you attached.

A $10 gift card for any review sounds simple. Without disclosure, moderation, and honest-collection guardrails, it becomes regulatory risk and worthless one-line praise.

This guide is not legal advice. Consult counsel for your jurisdiction and use case.

FTC endorsement basics

The FTC expects:

  • Honest opinions — reviewers express their genuine experience
  • Clear disclosure — material connections (payment, free product, discounts) are visible
  • No misleading claims — you cannot fabricate or substantially alter reviews
  • Equal treatment — do not suppress negative incentivized reviews selectively

Testimonials vs reviews: definitions and placement. Fake review prevention: spot fake reviews.

Incentives that stay ethical

Incentive type Notes
Entry into a drawing Disclose odds and sponsor; no review required to enter (optional feedback OK)
Small thank-you credit For completing feedback — not conditioned on star rating or positive tone
Early access / beta perks Disclose relationship; common in SaaS
Charitable donation per response Disclose amount and charity; do not require positive review

Avoid: pay only for 5 stars, delete negative reviews from incentivized cohorts, or staff-written "customer" quotes.

Disclosure requirements

Place disclosure where shoppers see the review:

  • On-site widget — "Reviewer received [incentive]" label on applicable reviews
  • Review profile page — program terms linked from footer or review metadata
  • Collection flow — reviewer sees disclosure before submitting
  • Email invite — state incentive in the ask email, not hidden in terms

PraiseEngine moderation lets you tag and approve incentivized reviews with visible labels before they publish — you control what goes live on your first-party site.

What to avoid

  • Buying reviews from non-customers
  • Incentivizing only positive reviews or only publishing 5-star responses
  • AI-generated reviews presented as customer-written
  • Hiding incentive relationship in fine print
  • Review gating — survey route: happy → public review, unhappy → private only

Approve-before-publish: why moderation matters. Negative review responses: response guide.

Collecting authentic incentivized reviews

  1. Offer incentive for honest feedback, any rating
  2. Link to guided AI interview — produces narrative from customer's words
  3. Customer approves draft before submit; you moderate before publish
  4. Label incentivized reviews on display widgets
  5. Publish negative but constructive reviews when authentic — builds trust

Guided interviews: how AI-guided collection works. Ask templates: how to ask customers for reviews.

Get started free — permanent Free plan.

Frequently asked questions

Is it legal to offer incentives for customer reviews?
In many jurisdictions, yes — when incentives are disclosed, not conditioned on a positive rating, and reviews reflect honest opinions. FTC rules in the US require clear disclosure of material connections. Consult legal counsel for your specific program.
What disclosure is required for incentivized reviews?
Shoppers must see that the reviewer received something of value — discount, gift card, free product, or entry into a promotion. Disclosure should appear where the review is displayed and in the collection flow before submission.
Can you offer a discount for leaving a 5-star review?
No. Conditioning incentives on star rating or positive sentiment violates FTC endorsement guidelines and platform policies on most marketplaces. Incentivize honest feedback regardless of rating.
How do you collect authentic reviews when offering an incentive?
Use guided interviews instead of blank forms, require customer approval of their draft, moderate before publish, label incentivized reviews on display, and publish constructive negative feedback when it is genuine.